I posed this question on Instagram and Facebook the other day, and there were many, many responses. I thought I’d copy and paste them and create an essay of sorts of what people had to say.
I wonder if some with no issues maybe just have not realized how much it affected them, it took into my sixties for realization of the extent it changed me and my life.
That biological connection is of no importance to me and my real family (the family that adopted me) has always been and will always be enough.
When you find out you’re adopted, you find out that something you’ve never questioned, your basic knowledge of the world - your identity and that of your family - is untrue. Non-adoptees might be able to grasp this on an intellectual level but only an adoptee can understand it in its essence.
I am able to love biological parents (whether we have met or not) just as I love the parents that raised me.
I can read the room like I’m a psychic.
I have so much love for my adoptive parents, but even so, meeting my biological family felt like coming home in a way I can’t put into words.
I am an adoptee and I adopted two children when they were babies. It is possible to feel blessed and cheated at the same time. I do believe God can use all things for good for those who love Him.
That i may not "remember" my mom or my relinquishing; I have never stopped loving and wanting her in my 60 years on earth.
I now lead my story with, I was separated from my mother at 5 days old. People immediately relate to their own memories of giving birth and imagining being separated from their baby.
"If you thought people would believe you." This is the message! This is for those who have not been believed to try and imagine a world where they ARE properly heard.
The popular narrative IS heard!
That it affects every facet of my life from day one, even now, fifty six years later.
That it actually does leave a permanent effect on the baby for life.
Some of us get re-homed!
That you can have wonderful adoptive parents and a good childhood, yet still feel like a big part of you doesn’t fully belong there.
That I was kidnapped and I'm still lost.
Eh, I personally wish I had my real family, but I know that life would have been limiting, poor, and rough. My birth dad put me up for adoption, because my birth mom died and he couldn't afford to take care of me and worried that I would die of starvation. It's common in India that girls aren't valued because they're expensive to marry, so he could have easily let me die. I admire him for being selfless and taking a chance on me having a better life. I did have a good life mostly and I really shouldn't complain but I never felt good enough with my adopted family.
I think my birth dad probably loved me so much, the kind of love I craved and I would have been happy to just be with him. As soon as I realized that, I decided I wanted to accomplish everything in his honor and really hope to make my way back to meet him someday. I gotta do it soon before we get too old.
I was also only 2 years old when I was out up for adoption.
I was also part of the native adoption plan..from California. My birth certificate said my father was the milk man.
Adoption was the best thing that could have ever happened to me at 21 months in 1964. My parents, (the ones who adopted me), worshipped me, and I them. We sometimes actually forgot I was adopted when discussing hereditary factors. When they both passed nine months apart, I lost my foundation. I miss them every minute of every day. We three were one. Any woman produce a child doesn’t make them a mother, it takes special people to love and raise them.
I was loved and looked after so well by my AP
I never asked about my BP my AM was surprised
A bit nosey now but I’ll live if I never find out.
That adoption can save children from horrible abuse.
My adopted mother is the true mother of my soul.
Infant adoptees know they're not with their natural families.
I don't know that anything that is true for me will across the board be true for every adoptee. I find myself ungrounded, unsupported and a lot of self identity starts with the foundation of where we come from and we build upon that and make our own way over time but adoptee's start with no foundation. Some adoptee's have good adopted families with a lot of love and support and they thrive but that’s not the norm.
Being willing to adopt someone else's child does not necessarily make them good people. You should check a couple of years after the adoption to see that they are not abusing the child. I was 2 the first time My adoptive mother broke one of my arms. I was 47 the day she slapped me so hard across the face that she broke my glasses. And all the days in between she was a horrible person. But she was a middle class white woman who adopted children out of the goodness of her soul. The truth found in her diary is she had been married 7 years and was ashamed of not having a child.
My adoptive famy kept me and my sister in contact with our biological family... I wish they wouldnt have. I wish I never knew them or saw them again. My adoptive family is my true family. The others have caused more pain.
Stop adopting children/babies because you are told to save them (biblical teaching) or because you can’t reproduce. These wants sound valid, but you are actually part of the problem. Once you act on this by adopting, you have had a hand in sustaining a market place for rehoming babies and children. Some states are enforcing policies to try to place the child with family first, but when non biological folks who want to adopt show up (usually with more financial resources) it challenges the system to hold the line on looking for a family member. Social workers can struggle with their recommendation about what is best for child and the placement. Take the non family members out of the equation. Unfortunately of course there will always be a need for a non family member to adopt because of family circumstances. Private industries have exploited children and created a market in which non family member adoptions are commonplace. The “need” of a childless couple has created a market , instead of the needs of the child being put out front. Adoption is a social issue, not a market share.
Even as a young child I knew something was off. When I was five years old I was ashamed of my dad (turns out adopted father) I knew he was wrong. (he had racist behavior) I was ashamed. Then in 3rd grade I told my mom (Adopted mom) someone had told me I was adopted. I don't think that is true. I don't think anyone said anything to me. Pretty sure I was in trouble for something. Anyway, it shut down the 'trouble' and she whipped out the baby book with all the proof that I was hers. I feel bad about that. Bad that I made her feel bad. She died sometime that year from a heart attack. She was older and I was black market adoption.
You can be surrounded by a whole adopted family and feel completely alone.
That it is the worst thing that ever happened to me, and abortion would have been infinitely kinder.
That even if adopted into the perfect family and always accepted, there is still a feeling of disconnection and loss.
I would say that the adoption system and concept promotes the colonizer ideologies of taking what they want. It exploits people in poverty, young women, undereducated folks and traffics children all over the world legally. I would say sure some children had good experiences (some slaves had nice masters), and then there was the majority especially those raised in interracial families, or interracial international families who not only may have been stolen from their land, but then also stripped of their identities. Expected to conform, and become who their adopters wanted them to be and do it with gratitude. I would say in the same breath I am grateful for the life I have now and therefore have gratitude towards my adopted family from bringing me here, and also was contactless for 10 years and most recently my adopted mother passed and I have struggled with the grieving process. Because little me 3,4,5 year old me grieves the mother figure that was present. Adult me doesn’t understand why when I was little the “adoption poem” was instilled in me, and the your not from my belly your from my heart nonsense and then as an adult and in her dying she actively planned for her family to receive the heirlooms (my cousins) because she had no bio family. I would tell people if they want to adopt EDUCATE yourself! Acknowledge that the child you are bringing into your home comes from other people, and that child carries that in their body and soul. Learn their people! If you are adopting interracial learning how to do their hair, connect them with the foods of their people, teach them about their cultural holidays, make sure you expose them to people who look like them, connect them with their first language. Understand that their experience in life will be different, look at your community before you adopt a child into it, just because you think brown babies are cute (if you have family that are active Klan members) maybe a brown baby isn’t what you should bring to your community (true story). Ugh I could talk on this topic for hours!
I was born in a Salvation Army facility in Spokane WA in 1946… I was the Result of a date rape situation and I was with my Birthmom till my birth and then they separated us but we were in same building for 19 days till I was sent to Lewiston ID hospital and Birthmom went home to Oregon..
I went from Hospital to Children’s home back door and after a brief time went out the front door with my adoptive parents…Found my Birthmother in 1977 and we had 20 years together.. along with my 4 half brothers… and a huge family tree.. I found Birthfather in 1992 and he has passed in the late 70’s but I got a half brother and half sister and aunts, uncles and a paternal grandmother who was 96 and never knew I existed.. but her family tree includes many Roosevelts including Teddy, Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt.. and families are all apart of my world.. adopted parents died in 1980 and 1982 only 1 cousin that is left. I am very blessed to have had so many wonderful people in my birth family… and I cherish them all…
Those people still feel like strangers to me at 44 years old.
That even if you were adopted in absolute infancy and your adoptive parents loved you to the moon and were absolutely your family and did the best they could by you, it still matters that you were adopted. That separation at the start is still there.
All the comments makes me so sad . Adoption can be a lot of things. Good, bad, but it definitely leaves a lifelong mark on you…
I was stolen and abused and wish I could annul it.
They didn’t love me.
That the trauma is real.
Avant une adoption, il y a la séparation maternelle, souvent dès la naissance, qui laisse des séquelles à vie (cf The primal wound - Nancy Newton Verrier). La plupart des parents adoptifs ne nous auraient jamais adoptés s'ils avaient eu leur propre "progéniture" (nous sommes un produit de remplacement qui ne sera jamais à la hauteur des attentes des parents adoptifs et facile à rejeter) et ils restent blessés par leur stérilité. L'enfant, le nourrisson souvent, cassé par la séparation maternelle arrive chez un couple adoptif souffrant et doit souvent en porter le poids.
Il est grand temps de repenser à la fin des orphelinats (qui font du trafic sur notre dos) : cf vidéo Tara Winkler's TEDxSydney talk, "Why we need to end the era of orphanages" (2016).
(TRANSLATION)
Before adoption, there is the mother's separation, often from birth, which leaves lifelong scars (cf The primal wound - Nancy Newton Verrier). Most adoptive parents would never have adopted us if they had their own "offspring" (we are a replacement product that will never meet the expectations of adoptive parents and is easy to reject) and they remain hurt by their sterility. The child, often the infant, broken by the mother's separation, arrives at an adoptive couple suffering and often has to bear the burden.
It is high time to rethink the end of orphanages (which traffic us on our backs): cf video Tara Winkler's TEDxSydney talk, "Why we need to end the era of orphanages" (2016).
I am so happy I am reading this before I adopt.
People are not secrets.
That it was a trauma, and the reason for my mental health issues among other things.
It’s lifelong grief and challenges
That despite having wonderful adoptive parents since I was 3 weeks old, those feelings of abandonment from your birth parents never really go away.
When non adopted people talk about how wonderful adoption is and how we should be grateful, ask them "which of their children they would they give away". A lot happens in utero, and when your birth mother is ashamed that she is pregnant and stressed and worried throughout her pregnancy that her family will find out she's pregnant etc, all of that impacts the baby in the womb. Then you are handed over to nuns in an orphanage after a couple of days and join a load of other abandoned babies being cared for and fed by a range of different staff members until they find you your 'forever home'. You are then handed to complete strangers to take home like some cute little puppy where you are expected to fit in and grow up just like them, because 'love is all that matters' and no one understands what you have already been through. 'The Body Keeps the Score' by Bessel van der Kolk explains it far better than I can.
The severing of the mother from the infant has a profound impact on brain and emotional development. I still can’t self regulate. My nervous system is easily overwhelmed. My cognitive brain goes bye-bye and it’s all fight/flight, freeze, or fawn… lifelong impact.
That I was sold from a christian adoption agency in Canada. I am a survivor of the 60s scoop.
For some of us, it causes lifelong identity issues. And no, I can’t just “get over it”.
That when you are abandoned at birth, the fear response continues for a lifetime in everything you do. You never feel safe, the bond you deveoped over 9 months is immediatelyshattered.. You feel like an alien, unloved, disconnected and unwanted. Anxiety and depression is inevitable for those already genetically at risk. You may be provided with all the things you require from your adoptive parents, but your neurological development was stunted after relinquishment and abandonment.
Not knowing who looks like you, never having seen anybody that looks like you, and the only way to meet one is to make one. But that adoption trauma has killed any spark of paternity within me.
It should be illegal. Stop changing birth certificates. Institute Stewardship instead.
I could've had better...
That the constant litany of unwanted pregnancy/chosen child is harmful. That there are reasons why ww are so overrepresented in stats for suicide ànd self harm and lots of other painful outcomes. That peoole hoping to adopt àre presenting their best faces, not necessarily their true faces to the world when advertising for babies ànd when having home studies done. That it is a conflict of interest, allowing agencies that rely on the money they make from adoptions to be the same people performing home studies ànd providing other services like record maintenance and after adoption supports.
That lies àre not meant to protect the adoptee but to make things easier for the agencies and the adopters.
That many adoptees say we are okay publicly but say something very different when in private adoptee spaces, because to do anything other than parrot the happy adoptee narrative feels dangerous.
That many cultures manage to provide feelings of belonging and affection without erasing a persons identity, extended family ties, connections to culture and language and history.
I’ll remember when I was at school, we had to do a family tree and I remember that my adoptive mum gave me all the information on their family, but in fact it wasn’t my family tree I’ll never forget that Feeling of not belonging
It fundamentally and completely altered the entire course of my life... And it wasn't the adoption, it was the complete separation from my mother.
People may not realize this but in addition to secrets causing issues. Secrets also create an automatic barrier between adoptee and adopted parents.
That if the maternal adopter dies guaranteed the paternal one will drop you like a lead balloon.
Adoption is not for casual selling of children for profit by for profit businesses. Adoption is the last possible resort for a child in crisis who needs responsible adults to care for them. It is not a family building tool to be used for adult wants.
There is no foundation. You literally have to piece together your whole story. You will have to work on your own foundation your entire life.
Its often Lonely.
bring adopted doesn't always mean u had a better life . i always wonder wat my life would have been like if my bio mom would have kept me or if she would have allowed my bio dad a chance at raising me.
If you are adopted late like I was ( age 5 ), you can’t win. Adoptive family wants you to be grateful for what you have, and I do, but that doesn’t eliminate the grieving process. Our experiences can not be easily explained to non adoptees. Bio side, you escaped the abuse, be happy. I feel pulled in so many directions, by all involved with my adoption.
Early infant maternal separation causes a baby a broken heart.
You NEVER feel truly loved like the rest of the family, and never feel like you belong anywhere .... When they talk about family tree's in school, it hits you like a bullet .... It never feels like ' home '
Nothing! Non adopted people do not believe anything other than the fairytale and gratitude!
That it’s the worst thing that ever happened to me.
Adoption robbed me of who I should have been
That there is a deep unresolveable longing in your heart and soul to be loved even though you may be surrounded by people who do love you. That you always feel a low key loneliness especially in times when you "should" be happy (birthdays, Christmas...) and you have to keep it all to yourself so as not to make your adoptive family feel unappreciated.
Sigh....
Adoption stole from me far more than it ever gave
It's built on many lies that break a little bit of everyone who engages in the fantasy.
Its mentally damaging when everyone tells you how lucky you are and mean while you feel like your missing a part of your body , you constantly feel like something bad is going to happen or your going to die ...
Not my job to educate them.
That I was just a pawn in someone else’s game. Some adults want to feel control, and so some will turn to adoption, or call CPS on a mother with the hope that their child/children will be taken away. It’s a control game at its core. It’s a legal form of human trafficking, and many people enjoy that thought (they’ll never admit that though). Unfortunately the adoptees, birth mothers and first families are the soul victims in this process. If we had supports for mothers and children, we wouldn’t have as much adoption happening. I think that’s an incredibly hard truth that the public refuses to sit with. It’s a societal failure, and society continues to blame the victims of this travesty as if their trauma is their own fault, and they deserved it. Constant. Blame.
Adoption is the use of State Power to have someone declared “as if born to” the petitioner(s)
Nothing to do with child welfare. Nothing to do with love. It’s a legal process: the child is a subject of it and not a party. It’s not necessary to care for a child in need.
I can’t put it into words and I would never wish it upon anyone.
That you always feel like you’re on the outside looking in- no matter how loved you are by your adoptive family.
I know when someone is trying to hide something from me.
That the grief and the lack-of-belonging is never-ending. And that a lot of us have something like Stockholm syndrome with our adopters.
Adoption is guaranteed to provide a whole host of problems that are unique to adoption. Some day's the pain is just unimaginable.
It felt like an abduction that I should be “grateful for”
While adopting can be a blessing it can also be a curse that separates biological siblings and is founded upon loss.
It is just another way to get your parents.
It made literally everything harder.
Everyone thinks I was saved! They gave me a better life!
My adopted dad molested me. He's my bio dad's uncle. He doesn't believe me.
Same.
For many, Adoption is a life long sentence of cruel and unusual punishment.
To be frank....It sucks!!!
It’s trauma, and it should be abolished and replaced with another model of child welfare. We need to stop allowing people to pretend other people’s children are theirs. It’s the epitome of conditional love.
People don't want to hear about all the physical abuse & psychological warfare I've been through during my 65 years. I'm expected to be grateful that they didn't succeed in killing me. They tried quite a few times over the years, and even tried to get me to kill myself.
It’s a crime against humanity and the infinite plan of God….
That Adoption, in my experience is not right for everyone.
It is the worst thing that has ever happened to me.
It’s a life sentence. Not a blessing. AT ALL.
I would like to know what it feels like to live on this earth without the pressure/guilt/duty of being an adopted daughter. Because of my cancer diagnosis, my a-parents are most likely going to out live me and I will not have 1 minute of freedom in this life time.
That for the unbearable weight of the trauma caused by being an adoptee over 57 years, which seems to extrapolate as the years go on, I would have much preferred to have been aborted.
That many times adoption doesn’t equal a happy ending. That it’s extremely selfish to have kids that you know you can’t be a parent to or take care of. That it is much better in many cases to choose abortion. The outcome of adoption is never guaranteed, and as a parent it is your job to make sure that your kids are well loved. You can’t do that when you choose adoption. You can’t do that if you have kids that are taken from you and placed into the system. You have to trust that a complete stranger will somehow love your kids as much as you do, and as an adoptee with my own child, I think that’s close to impossible. I can acknowledge that it does happen in some cases however.
I love my adopted parents more than I can say! There’s no inferiority. They are my real family!
Makes absolutely no difference..
Back in 1950 abortion was available only for the wealthy and well connected. My Mother was neither. Yes, everything would have been so much better if I had been aborted.
It’s child trafficking with a legalized bow hidden by propaganda held up by the courts. Life long witness protection and a human rights issue. It is a global industry that commodified the child.
They only wanting the money the benefits blessings them they gather to remove plott we never heard of such today bring killed sacrificed plot to
Kill it’s awful three lie we didn’t do it ! Look at those who would trade you away fir money that’s not genuine love being trafficked as a baby and mistreated all your life to go through hell.
That having to do genealogy and DNA assignments in biology about what traits you get from your parents sucks.